The song received positive reviews from critics, who praised its conception and production. Musically, "Push the Button" is an electropop and R&B song with various computer effects.
Composed by Dallas Austin and the Sugababes, it was inspired by an infatuation that group member Keisha Buchanan developed with another artist. The song became the group's first top 10 single on the Romanian Singles Chart since "Round Round" in 2002."Push the Button" is a song by English girl group the Sugababes, released as the lead single from their fourth studio album Taller in More Ways (2005). In the Netherlands, "Push the Button" peaked at #3 spending 23 weeks on the chart, and is tied with "Hole in the Head" as their biggest hit, which peaked at #3 in 2003.Song also topped MTV Adria top 20 Chart. Also in Sweden, "Push the Button" peaked at #4 to become the Sugababes' most successful single to date. The song was also successful in France, a difficult market for the group in the past, peaking at #17 and where it is their highest peaking single to date. The single was also a club hit in the United States. It was certified Platinum by ARIA making it their best selling Australian single ahead of "Round Round" which peaked at #13 in 2002, which was certified gold.
"Push the Button" debuted at #24 and peaked at #3 in Australia, making it their highest charting Australian single and biggest hit. The girls received their second 'best British single' nomination at the 2006 BRIT Awards, but lost the award to Coldplay's Speed of Sound. "Push the button" also peaked at #2 in Germany with sales over 150,000 and also peaked at #2 in Norway, and #3 in Switzerland. "Push The Button" became the Sugababes' most successful single to date worldwide peaking at #1 the singles charts in the UK, Republic of Ireland, New Zealand,Croatia,Serbia, Austria and Poland. "We end up with Mr 'Too Cool', Mr 'Perfect' and Mr 'Shy Guy' (Emrhys Cooper) and of course we flirt with them, tease them and push them away… all in a fun way." "So there's Keisha, Heidi in a lift and on each floor that the lifts stops at, a different guy gets in, one for each of us," Mutya Buena told in an interview with the band's official website. The video primarily focuses around Buena, Buchanan and Range dancing in an elevator for an extremely tall (and computer animated) building. It was filmed in various locations throughout Shepherds Bush, London in July 2005 and first aired in the United Kingdom in the week of September 12, 2005. The music video for "Push the Button" was directed by American director Matthew Rolston and produced by Lindsay Turnham for Exposure Films. The single was featured on the soundtrack for the 2006 romantic comedy It's a Boy/Girl Thing, and in a commercial for Tassimo coffee machines. In the UK the maxi CDs release was on September 26, 2005. Thematically, the electro influenced pop song focuses upon how a girl tries to wrap a man around the little finger, prompting him to "push the button" instead of hesitating any longer. It reached number one in Austria, Ireland, Poland, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom, becoming the group's fourth number one single domestically. Produced by Dallas, the song was released to positive reaction from music critics as the album's lead single in September 2005. "Push the Button" is a pop song written by Dallas Austin, Mutya Buena, Keisha Buchanan, and Heidi Range for the Sugababes' fourth studio album Taller in More Ways (2005).